Opinion may be divided on whether the edits open the music up to new and interesting interpretations or whether, crudely put, it's a bastardisation of classic songs that should have been left alone. The fact that I've compiled and posted this selection probably tells you which way I'm dancing (badly) on this one.
1) This Must Be The Place (Naive Edit By Psychemagik): Talking Heads (2010)
2) Arabian Knights (Mojo Filter Banshee Edit): Siouxsie & The Banshees (2012)
3) Rock The Casbah (Luxxury Edit): The Clash (2013)
4) It's My LIfe (The Reflex Re√ision): Talk Talk (2019)
5) Going Underground (The Reflex Re√ision): The Jam (2017)
6) Blue Monday (Luxxury 'How Does It Feel' Edit): New Order (2016)
7) Rapture (The Reflex Re√ision): Blondie (2017)
Intriguing, looking forward to hearing this - all new to me
ReplyDeleteMany thanks, middle aged man, I hope you enjoyed it
DeleteI've listened to it 2 or 3 times and I must admit its weird listening to songs I know inside out sounding different- there are a couple songs which I think if I had heard first I would prefer especially the Siouxsie one, but overall would agree with your summary 'none of them can beat the brilliance of the originals' - Thank you - it was fun
DeleteI quite like the inclusion of the child choir on This Must Be The Place but it slightly outstays its welcome overall. Then again, it was probably designed for DJing out not for repeated listening at home, so I get the point. I think I prefer Blue Monday to many of the 'contemporary' remixes that followed. It retains enough of the original but takes it in a pleasingly different direction. Thanks for your follow up comments after a few listens, middle aged man, they're always appreciated.
DeleteAgree with middle aged man - looking forward to this!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Mike. Between them, there are hundreds of re-edits out there, not all of which hit the spot, but I think they've done a pretty good job with this selection
DeleteStating the obvious but, good as these reimagined versions are, none of them can beat the brilliance of the originals...
ReplyDelete